My review of the Gothic combination

Why this combination when you're coming for Saint-Denis?

The two sites tell the same story a hundred years apart. In Saint-Denis, in 1144, Abbot Suger had a choir built with radiating chapels that opened into one another, allowing a light he called lux nova to pass through. This marked the birth of Gothic architecture, and it can still be seen today when you look up in the ambulatory. At the Sainte-Chapelle, the concept is taken to its extreme: the walls have practically disappeared in favour of glass. Seeing both in the same visit means witnessing an idea come to life and then reach its limit.

The Conciergerie, with the same ticket, adds the other thread. This is where Marie-Antoinette was imprisoned before her execution; her remains, buried in the Madeleine cemetery, were sought and brought back to Saint-Denis in January 1815, where Louis XVIII had a praying statue erected for her. The two monuments thus also correspond in this way, and the page dedicated to the two remains recounts the transfer. The HistoPad, the tablet offered on site, is available in six languages.

What comes up in the reviews

Across more than ten thousand reviews, it’s always the same phrase, written in a thousand ways. Stephanie (United Kingdom): « As soon as I climbed the stairs and saw the stained glass, I was left breathless. » Jane (Australia) puts it differently: « Photos don’t do the place justice. » These two reviews highlight something useful for those planning their day: the upper chapel is revealed all at once, at the top of a narrow staircase, and the effect depends greatly on the light at that moment. On overcast days, it’s less spectacular.

The third recurring point is the commentary. Kenneth (United States): « The audio guide was very useful and well done. » This is the opposite of what you read about Saint-Denis, where Régis advises abandoning the audio guides and waiting for the free guided tour. The difference is simple and not due to the equipment: at Saint-Denis, a human-guided tour in French is included in the ticket at 11 a.m. and 3 p.m. Elsewhere, it is not. When there is no guide, the tablet becomes the best choice.

The 4.4 rating is mainly explained by the queue and security checks on the Île de la Cité, which are on a completely different scale from what you experience at Saint-Denis. This is also why I recommend starting with Saint-Denis in the morning and then heading down: the reverse means arriving at rue de la Légion d’Honneur tired, in the late afternoon, when the light in the ambulatory dims.

For whom, and for whom not

For whom: those who want to understand what Saint-Denis invented, by seeing it applied elsewhere. Those who follow Marie-Antoinette’s story, from her prison to her praying statue — the full account is on the page dedicated to her. Those who love stained glass, and will find at Saint-Denis an older collection, explained on the stained glass page.

For whom not: those who only have half a day, and would be better off spending it entirely at Saint-Denis with the included guided tour. Those who struggle with crowds and checks. Those whose plans may change: the ticket is non-refundable, which is not the case for the audio tour or the behind-the-scenes tour of the Stade de France. The day’s organisation is detailed on the combined visit page, and the birth of Gothic art on Suger and Gothic art.

Frequently asked questions